CONTENTS

Nominee Is Not the Owner: Will vs Nomination vs Joint Holding in India

Every year I meet families who believe their succession planning is finished because every account has a nominee. The belief is common enough that it survives contact with bank staff, insurance agents and sometimes even lawyers. It is also wrong, and the Supreme Court has been saying so for forty years.

A nominee is a receiver, nothing more. Who owns the money after you die is decided by your will, and if there is no will, by succession law. Those are two separate questions, and most households have answered only the first.

This article covers what a nomination actually does, where joint holding helps, what the law does with your money if you die without a will, and the arithmetic of who gets how much. Every legal point is drawn from the statutes and judgments listed at the end.

What a nomination actually does

A nomination tells the institution, whether it is the bank or the AMC or the depository, one thing: after my death, hand the asset to this person and consider your job done. It protects the institution from having to referee a family dispute. It says nothing about who finally owns the money.

The courts have been consistent about this across asset classes.

Asset What the nominee is in law Authority
Life insurance Receiver for the legal heirs, with one exception covered below Sarbati Devi v. Usha Devi, Supreme Court, 1984
Bank deposits Receiver; payment discharges the bank, not the heirs’ claims Section 45ZA, Banking Regulation Act; Ram Chander Talwar v. Devender Kumar Talwar, Supreme Court, 2010
Shares, demat, mutual funds Holds the securities for the heirs; succession law prevails Shakti Yezdani v. Jayanand Salgaonkar, Supreme Court, December 2023
Cooperative society flat Society must transfer membership to the nominee, but this does not decide title between heirs Indrani Wahi v. Registrar of Cooperative Societies, Supreme Court, 2016

The Shakti Yezdani judgment deserves a sentence more, because people kept hoping securities were somehow different. A shareholder had made nominations and his heirs claimed the estate anyway. In December 2023 the Supreme Court held that nomination under the Companies Act and the Depositories Act does not override succession law, and that “vesting” in the nominee means temporary holding for administration, not ownership.

So when your bank relationship manager says “nominee ho jayega, kaam ho gaya,” the accurate translation is that the bank’s paperwork is done. Yours is not.

None of this makes nomination useless. Its real job is liquidity. With a valid nomination the institution releases the money in days against simple documents, and without one, and without a will, the family may need a succession certificate from a court, which takes months. So nominate everywhere. Just do not confuse it with deciding who inherits.

The nomination rules themselves were overhauled recently. Bank depositors can name up to four nominees with percentage shares from 1 November 2025 under the Banking Laws (Amendment) Act 2025. SEBI’s revised framework, effective 1 September 2026, allows up to three nominees per demat account or mutual fund folio, and it is mandatory for new single-holder accounts unless you opt out in writing. I have covered the mechanics of the September 2026 rules in the piece on how organised families run their money, so I will not repeat them here.

The insurance exception

Life insurance is the one place where a nominee can be more than a receiver. The Insurance Laws (Amendment) Act 2015 added Section 39(7) to the Insurance Act: where the nominee is the policyholder’s spouse, child or parent, the nominee is “beneficially entitled” to the claim amount. Lawyers call this a beneficial nominee.

Two cautions before you rely on it. It applies only to those three relationships, so if you nominate a brother or a friend the old rule applies and they receive the money for the heirs. And the High Courts are still not unanimous that a beneficial nominee defeats every succession claim. The Allahabad High Court has held that even a Section 39(7) nominee cannot extinguish the rights of other legal heirs. The clean solution is the same as everywhere else: make the will say the same thing the nomination says.

What joint holding gives you, and what it does not

An “either or survivor” bank account or a jointly held mutual fund folio solves a real problem, which is continuity. The surviving holder can operate the account the day after the death, pay the hospital bill, keep the SIPs running. For a married couple’s day-to-day accounts I consider it close to essential.

But survivorship is about access, not inheritance. The RBI’s directions on settlement of deceased customers’ claims spell this out. The bank’s payment to a survivor or nominee is a valid discharge for the bank, but it “shall not affect the right or claim which any person may have against the survivor,” who receives the money as a trustee of the legal heirs. Put that on the ₹20,00,000 fixed deposit in the example below: your wife as surviving joint holder can withdraw the whole ₹20,00,000 the week after the funeral, the bank is fully protected for having paid her, and your mother can still lawfully ask her for a share of that same money two years later. The bank’s discharge ends the bank’s problem, not the family’s.

Joint holding also has side effects people forget. Both holders’ deaths have to be planned for, since an either-or-survivor account with no nomination and no will leaves the heirs back at the succession certificate. The asset shows on both balance sheets. And adding a joint holder to an existing investment can itself amount to a gift, with tax consequences. It is a convenience tool, not a substitute for a will.

Who gets the money when there is no will

Now the part that actually decides ownership. If you die intestate, meaning without a valid will, a statute distributes your estate by formula. It pays no regard to who needed what, who looked after you, or what you said at the dinner table.

For Hindus, Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists, the Hindu Succession Act 1956 applies. For a man, Section 8 sends the estate to the Class I heirs: his widow, his mother, and each son and daughter, with children of any predeceased child stepping into that child’s share. They all take simultaneously and equally. Note who is on that list and who is not. The father is not a Class I heir. The mother is.

Christians are governed by the Indian Succession Act 1925. Where there is a widow and children, the widow takes one third and the children share two thirds (Section 33). Muslims are governed by their personal law, which has its own fixed shares, and if that is your situation please take specific advice, because the framework is entirely different.

A worked example: dividing a ₹1.5 crore estate

Say a 52-year-old Hindu businessman in Ahmedabad dies without a will. He is survived by his mother, his wife, a son and a daughter. His estate:

Asset Value Paperwork
Flat, in his sole name ₹90,00,000 No nomination possible
Mutual funds ₹40,00,000 Wife is sole nominee
Bank FD ₹20,00,000 Wife is joint holder, either or survivor
Total estate ₹1,50,00,000

Step 1: count the Class I heirs. Mother, widow, son, daughter = 4 heirs.

Step 2: equal division of the whole estate.

₹1,50,00,000 ÷ 4 = ₹37,50,000 per heir

Step 3: compare that with what the paperwork delivers. The AMC pays the wife ₹40,00,000 as nominee and the bank lets her keep operating the ₹20,00,000 FD as survivor, so ₹60,00,000 lands in her hands against a lawful entitlement of ₹37,50,000. The extra ₹22,50,000 she holds in trust for the other three. And the flat, which is 60 percent of the estate and has no nomination route at all, simply becomes co-owned: each of the four holds an undivided one-fourth share worth ₹22,50,000 on paper, which in practice means nobody can sell it unless all four sign.

Notice where that leaves the mother. Her entitlement is ₹37,50,000, but the liquid assets have already gone to her daughter-in-law and the rest of her share is locked inside a flat she cannot sell alone. To get her money she has to ask her son’s widow for it, or go to court. That is how cases between grieving relatives begin. A two-page will saying “everything to my wife,” or “the flat to my wife and the investments equally among all four,” would have prevented every line of this paragraph.

When a married woman dies without a will

Section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act governs a Hindu woman’s intestate estate, and its order surprises almost everyone I teach. Her property goes first to her children and husband. If she has no children, it does not go next to her parents. It goes to her husband, and if he is also gone, to her husband’s heirs. Her own mother and father stand behind her in-laws in the queue.

Say a 34-year-old salaried woman has built ₹60,00,000 of mutual funds from her own income. She is married, has no children, and dies without a will. Her husband takes the entire ₹60,00,000 and her parents receive nothing. Change one fact, that her husband died before her, and the ₹60,00,000 goes to his heirs, which can mean a brother-in-law, before it ever reaches her own mother. Section 15(2) adds one more twist: property she inherited from her father returns to her father’s heirs if she has no children.

For young working women this is, in my view, the single strongest argument for writing a will early. If you want your parents provided for, the law will not do it for you.

The paperwork a family faces without a will

Without a will and without nominations, movable assets like deposits and securities typically require a succession certificate from a civil court under Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act. That means a petition, notices, court fees charged as a percentage of the asset value, and commonly six months or more. Immovable property needs mutation backed by heirship documents, and any one disgruntled heir can stall everything.

One genuinely good piece of news: the Repealing and Amending Act 2025, assented on 20 December 2025, omitted Section 213 of the Indian Succession Act. Probate of a will is no longer mandatory even in Mumbai, Chennai and Kolkata, where it used to be compulsory for most communities. Probate remains available where a family wants a court’s seal on the document, but the default cost and delay is gone.

A will itself needs less ceremony than people assume. It must be in writing, signed by the testator, and attested by two witnesses. Registration is optional, though it adds evidentiary weight. If your situation is simple, meaning one house, some investments and one set of intended heirs, a plain will drafted carefully at home or with a lawyer for a modest fee solves ninety percent of this. You do not need an expensive estate planner, and you certainly do not need a course, to get the basics right.

Putting the three tools together

Three layers, three different jobs. The will decides ownership. The nominations, kept consistent with the will, decide speed, so the institutions release money in days instead of after a court process. Joint holding on the operating bank account decides continuity, so the household bills get paid in the meantime.

Trouble starts when the layers contradict each other. Take the family in the example above. If that businessman had written a will leaving the flat to his mother, but left his wife as sole nominee on the mutual funds and sole survivor on the FD, his mother’s ₹37,50,000 would be tied up in property while all ₹60,00,000 of the liquid money sat with someone else. The will would be perfectly valid and the family would still be in court.

So the review is worth doing once a year, and it takes an evening. Open each bank account, each folio, the demat account and every insurance policy, and write down the nominee on each one. Put that list next to your will. Where the two disagree, change the nomination, because the easier document to amend is the nomination. Then tell one person in the family which cupboard the will is in.

Succession is one of those areas where advisors earn trust for life, which is why estate planning gets a full module, the FPSB Risk and Estate Planning Specialist, in the CFP curriculum we teach at House of Financial Planners. But as a reader you do not need any of that to act this week. Write the will, align the nominations, and tell your family where the papers are.

Frequently asked questions

Does a nominee legally own the money after the account holder dies?

No, except in one case. For bank deposits, mutual funds, shares and cooperative society flats, the Supreme Court has consistently held that the nominee receives the asset as a trustee for the legal heirs, and ownership follows the will or intestate succession law. The exception is a life insurance nominee who is the policyholder’s spouse, child or parent, who is beneficially entitled under Section 39(7) of the Insurance Act, though some High Courts have still protected other heirs’ claims even there.

What happens to a bank account if there is no nominee and no will?

The bank will settle the balance in favour of the legal heirs, but only against documents: typically a legal heir certificate for smaller balances under the bank’s threshold, or a succession certificate issued by a civil court under Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act for larger ones. Court fees are charged as a percentage of the asset value and the process commonly takes several months. A nomination avoids this entirely, which is its real purpose.

Does a will need to be registered or probated to be valid?

No. A will is valid if it is in writing, signed by the testator and attested by two witnesses; registration is optional and adds evidentiary strength. Since the Repealing and Amending Act 2025 omitted Section 213 of the Indian Succession Act in December 2025, probate is no longer mandatory anywhere in India, including Mumbai, Chennai and Kolkata, though it remains available voluntarily.

Who inherits if a married Hindu man dies without a will?

His Class I heirs under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act take the estate in equal shares: his widow, his mother, and each son and daughter, with children of a predeceased child stepping into that child’s share. A widow does not automatically get everything; if a man leaves a wife, a mother and two children, each of the four receives one fourth of the entire estate.

Is making my spouse a joint holder enough instead of writing a will?

No. Survivorship gives your spouse operational access and discharges the bank, but the RBI’s own directions state the survivor receives the money as a trustee of the legal heirs, whose claims survive the payment. Joint holding is excellent for continuity in the weeks after a death, and it pairs well with a will, but it does not decide final ownership.

Sources

  • Shakti Yezdani v. Jayanand Jayant Salgaonkar, Supreme Court of India, 14 December 2023: https://indiankanoon.org/doc/166607072/
  • Indrani Wahi v. Registrar of Cooperative Societies, Supreme Court of India, 10 March 2016: https://indiankanoon.org/doc/13253533/
  • Bar and Bench, “Nomination is not succession: Why a nominee does not always become the owner” (covering Sarbati Devi 1984, Ram Chander Talwar 2010 and Section 45ZA): https://www.barandbench.com/view-point/nomination-is-not-succession-why-a-nominee-does-not-always-become-the-owner
  • Trilegal, “The Rights of Nominees of Insurance Policies Explained” (Section 39(7), Insurance Laws (Amendment) Act 2015): https://trilegal.com/news-insights/thoughtleadership-tanmay-mondaq-the-rights-of-nominees-of-insurance-policies-explained/
  • Section 15, Hindu Succession Act 1956: https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1202482/
  • iPleaders, “The Hindu Succession Act, 1956: An ultimate guide” (Section 8 and Class I heirs): https://blog.ipleaders.in/the-hindu-succession-act-1956/
  • Law Section, “Indian Succession Act, 1925 Part V: Intestate Succession for Christians” (Section 33): https://lawsection.in/indian-succession-act-1925-part-v-explained-ultimate-guide-to-intestate-succession-laws-for-christians-in-india-2026/
  • Fox Mandal, “Govt Scraps Mandatory Probate of Wills” (Repealing and Amending Act 2025, omission of Section 213): https://foxmandal.in/govt-scraps-mandatory-probate-of-wills-a-long-awaited-legislative-reset/
  • RBI, Settlement of Claims in respect of Deceased Customers of Banks Directions, 2025: https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/NotificationUser.aspx?Id=12901
  • Business Standard, “Banking Laws (Amendment) Act 2025 nomination rules effective November 1”: https://www.business-standard.com/finance/news/banking-laws-amendment-act-2025-nomination-rules-effective-november-1-125102301106_1.html
  • Value Research, “SEBI nomination rules, September 2026” (SEBI circular dated 29 May 2026, effective 1 September 2026): https://www.valueresearchonline.com/learn/stocks/sebi-demat-nomination-rules-september-2026/
  • EzyLegal, “Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act” (succession certificate for movable assets): https://www.ezylegal.in/blogs/understand-section-372-of-the-indian-succession-act-in-detail